In Federal Communications Commissioner Mignon Clyburn’s dissent from the lifting of Title II regulation on internet service providers, she called her statement a “eulogy.”
Twitter users alternately cheered and mourned the end of net neutrality, which was put in place under the Obama administration and lasted just two years before being lifted by a party-line, 3-2 vote at the FCC yesterday.
Clyburn said that, among other things, the FCC was ‘[pulling] its own teeth.”
My statement opposing the @FCC majority's repeal of #NetNeutrality.
Read here: https://t.co/qQ9ut15FkI pic.twitter.com/0Ik9y27jGX
— Mignon Clyburn (@MignonClyburn) December 14, 2017
On the other side, Chairman Ajit Pai is dancing:
What will you be able to do on the Internet after the @FCC repeals utility-style Internet regulations tomorrow? Everything. Here are a few examples. https://t.co/0P96Bp0xpP
— Ajit Pai (@AjitPai) December 13, 2017
(Which, side-note, apparently landed him in hot water:)
https://twitter.com/ceciliakang/status/941698705119473665
.@BrendanCarrFCC: "I am proud to help end this two-year experiment with heavy-handed regulation–this massive regulatory overreach."#FCCLive
— Evan Swarztrauber (@SayreEvan) December 14, 2017
Former FTC head says everybody should just calm down:
President Obama's first Federal Trade Commission Chairman on @ajitpaifcc's plan to restore Internet freedom: "Consumers will remain protected, and the internet will continue to thrive." https://t.co/WKWvDH4C1t
— Matthew Berry (@MatthewBerryDC) December 13, 2017
Predictably, ISPs were pleased with the news. Amazon, Facebook and Netflix were among the large tech companies who were not.
The vote to roll back #netneutrality rules was slammed by tech giants like Amazon, Facebook and Netflix.
It was applauded by internet service providers. https://t.co/JcYvwC5rAV pic.twitter.com/0VbY915xNW
— CNN (@CNN) December 15, 2017
We’re disappointed in the decision to gut #NetNeutrality protections that ushered in an unprecedented era of innovation, creativity & civic engagement. This is the beginning of a longer legal battle. Netflix stands w/ innovators, large & small, to oppose this misguided FCC order.
— netflix⁷ (@netflix) December 14, 2017
Meanwhile, wireless industry trade groups were generally pleased:
At #FCCOpenMtg, @AjitPaiFCC says the Restoring Internet Freedom Order will promote #wireless competition pic.twitter.com/lFvItB5gLy
— CTIA (@CTIA) December 14, 2017
With some possible caveats from industry experts:
Long term impact of yesterday
One view belowI am concerned that @FCC will become hyperpartisan and will further slow the already low productivity on nonpartisan #spectrum issues NOT pushed by NAB or @CTIA even if they don't conflict with megagroupshttps://t.co/dWy98mEI9P https://t.co/IkCmSdUDQc
— Michael Marcus (@MarcusSpecSoln) December 15, 2017
Sen. Ted Cruz did a bit of trolling:
Snowflake, believing online propaganda: "OMG w/o net neutrality, the Internet is gone!" Informed observer: "You know, the FCC issued that rule in 2015. The Internet grew up wonderfully free from govt regulation & this restores the status quo ante." Snowflake: "Uh, never mind…"
— Ted Cruz (@tedcruz) December 15, 2017
House Speaker Paul Ryan says throwing open access enforcement to the FTC was the right call:
This is the right call by @AjitPaiFCC and the @FCC. The way to keep the internet free and open and protect consumers is to crack down on internet service providers that would abuse open access. https://t.co/5kxwSZGJzt pic.twitter.com/oIiwSvKqbh
— Paul Ryan (@SpeakerRyan) December 14, 2017
Donald Trump Jr. weighed in (and was promptly informed that Pai was nominated to his chairmanship by Trump’s father):
I would pay good money to see all those people complaining about Obama’s FCC chairman voting to repeal #NetNeutality actually explain it in detail. I’d also bet most hadn’t heard of it before this week. #outrage
— Donald Trump Jr. (@DonaldJTrumpJr) December 15, 2017
And other Twitter uses responded with bleak humor, or (gasp) some introspection:
https://twitter.com/TimFederle/status/941387206316511232
https://twitter.com/NasMaraj/status/941383640700858368
Us: “How is twitter free? I’d pay for this shit”
FCC: “K”
Us: “Nah wait, i was just joking”
FCC: “bet.”
— mac (@MacDoesIt) December 14, 2017
Just googled “net neutrality”…yeah, we gotta keep that.
— DRAM back (@DRAMsaid) December 8, 2017
One of the clearer signs that the FCC’s rationale is rubbish is the talking point about how dismantling Net Neutrality will be good for “innovation.”
A term which has been used so often, and with so little historical perspective, as to make it meaningless.
— Librarianshipwreck (@libshipwreck) December 15, 2017
But is the battle over? Nope. A number of states promptly announced their intent to sue over the regulatory change, and Senator Ed Markey said he planned to introduce congressional action to reverse it.
https://twitter.com/JRosenworcel/status/941488716933189632
Several states have already announced lawsuits against the FCC to preserve #NetNeutrality regulations https://t.co/IpQTHHliEz
— WIRED (@WIRED) December 15, 2017
I plan to introduce a Congressional Review Act resolution that would restore the Open Internet Order and reverse the @FCC’s historic mistake of repealing #NetNeutrality. This fight is far from over. pic.twitter.com/FTyqf1U83X
— Ed Markey (@SenMarkey) December 14, 2017
Or, in short:
The political dumpster fire of #NetNeutrality is just heating up https://t.co/oQv3DdPFBI pic.twitter.com/ukRz46vTG6
— Fast Company (@FastCompany) December 15, 2017