The case for the closed Internet

by jscarbo

The other day I came home to find my daughter in front of the computer, talking on the phone with her friend, Natasha, as they were competing in a friendly game of penguin fishing.
That’s so last year, I thought. Having just returned from the WCA conference in San Jose, Calif., I was presented with a vision of the wireless future-a slightly new version from the one I know. In this new future, which will start to dawn in 2008, a plethora of consumer electronics devices will offer easy wide area Internet access. After you shoot some video of your kid’s basketball game, you can press a button and quickly send it off to Grandma Helen’s wireless notebook so she can see her grandson make the winning shot.
It’s easy to imagine this vision materializing. But the newest gaming gadgets already have Wi-Fi access built in. So how will WiMAX be better, other than expanded coverage? I think the answer is contrary to conventional thinking. Wi-MAX’s advantage could be that the network can be closed. Sprint Nextel Corp. said it is struggling with whether some devices should have open access to the Internet or be more like walled gardens.
The walled-garden approach makes sense to me in some instances.